← Outside

2017-01-01

Random Research

I paid people to answer important questions such as: Do you eat or drink soup? Do dinosaurs have souls?

A running collection of small, half-serious studies — the kind of question that’s more fun to actually run than to argue about. Most of these were settled with a few hundred Mechanical Turk workers and a long-suffering group of research assistants.

Do you eat or drink soup?

“Some time ago, I got into an argument with a friend over whether one ‘eats’ or ‘drinks’ soup.” So I asked 107 people to rate, on two 1–5 scales, how broth-like versus stew-like they pictured soup, and whether they’d say they “eat” or “drink” it. A modest but real correlation fell out: the more broth-like your mental image, the more likely you are to say you drink it.

Scatter plot: the more broth-like people pictured soup, the more they leaned toward "drinking" it (r = .25, p = .01).

Do dinosaurs have souls?

“As a kid, I often wondered if dinosaurs had souls, and if so, if they’d still be wandering the earth.” Naturally, I put the question to 1,000 people. The public was, predictably, divided.

Poll results from 1,000 people on whether dinosaurs had souls.

Oatmeal and pasta sauce

“I happen to think oatmeal, when mixed with pasta sauce, tastes like a not-too-unpleasant cross between paella, congee, and risotto. Everyone else apparently thinks I am out of my mind.” The data sided firmly with everyone else.

The public's verdict on oatmeal mixed with pasta sauce — overwhelmingly against me.

Does serving size change how healthy food looks?

I showed 203 people the same yogurt nutrition label — identical in every way except the printed serving size — and asked how healthy it looked.

The yogurt label as shown to one group.

The same label shown to the other group — identical, except the serving size is halved.

People rated the half-serving label (M = 3.81) as healthier than the whole-serving one (M = 3.41), t(199.92) = 2.07, p = .04. Same yogurt; smaller number; healthier.

Healthiness ratings: the half-serving label was rated healthier than the whole.

Anonymized feedback

Worried my research assistants were too polite to tell me how our lab meetings actually landed, I let six of them rate them anonymously. Mostly positive — with one response best described as “crazy.”

Anonymous research-assistant ratings of our lab meetings.

Crowdsourced event planning

My research assistants and I also outsourced a real decision to Mechanical Turk: what to do for our lab outing. The crowd picked option two. We went. There is photo evidence.

Mechanical Turk's vote on what to do for the lab outing — option two won.

My research assistants at the destination the internet chose.